United States
5 ranked
hotels in New York
0 MICHELIN Keys · 5 Forbes Five Star · 0 World's 50 Best placings
finehotels.world › Destinations › New York
Midtown suites, a Columbus Circle tower and downtown glass
New York has 5 hotels ranked in the finehotels.world index. Baccarat Hotel New York leads on prestige score at 5.07 out of 10, followed by Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown and Mandarin Oriental, New York. Of those, 5 hold a Forbes Five Star rating.
The New York properties recognised here are weighted toward Forbes Five Star, held by all five, rather than toward MICHELIN Keys. The classic end is Fifth Avenue: The St. Regis New York, built by John Jacob Astor IV in 1904 with its King Cole Bar mural, and Baccarat Hotel New York on 53rd Street opposite the Museum of Modern Art, where crystal is the organising motif.
Higher up and further out the character shifts. Mandarin Oriental, New York occupies floors 35 and above of the Columbus Circle tower with windows over Central Park, and Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown sits among the Tribeca and Financial District blocks.
| Hotel | Prestige | Distinctions | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Baccarat Hotel New YorkForbes · 114 rooms | 5.07 | Forbes Five Star |
| 2 | Four Seasons Hotel New York DowntownForbes · 189 rooms | 5.07 | Forbes Five Star |
| 3 | Mandarin Oriental, New YorkForbes · 251 rooms | 5.07 | Forbes Five Star |
| 4 | The St. Regis New YorkForbes · 238 rooms | 5.07 | Forbes Five Star |
| 5 | Trump International Hotel & Tower New YorkForbes | 5.07 | Forbes Five Star |
Prestige score is shown out of 10. Sources: MICHELIN Guide 2026 Key selection, Forbes Travel Guide 2026 Star Awards, The World’s 50 Best Hotels 2024 to 2026, La Liste 2026 Top 1000 Hotels.
Midtown between Fifth and Park Avenues holds the historic grand hotels and the shortest walks to the theatre district; the southwest corner of Central Park at Columbus Circle trades street life for elevation and park views; and downtown around Tribeca and Battery Park is quieter after dark with better restaurant density.
September to early December is the strongest and tightest stretch, covering the autumn cultural season and the weeks between Thanksgiving and New Year; late January and February are the softest, and humid July and August bring shorter business stays and more availability.
By prestige score, the three highest ranked hotels in New York are Baccarat Hotel New York, Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown, Mandarin Oriental, New York. The score is a composite of MICHELIN Keys, Forbes Travel Guide Five Star ratings, placements in The World's 50 Best Hotels for 2024, 2025 and 2026, and La Liste's hotel ratings. finehotels.world tracks 5 award holding hotels in New York in total.
New York has 0 hotels holding MICHELIN Keys in this index.
Each hotel is scored on a fixed formula built only from award facts, then shown on a scale of 5.00 to 10.00. MICHELIN Keys carry the most weight, a Forbes Travel Guide Five Star rating adds a flat six points, placements in The World's 50 Best Hotels for 2024, 2025 and 2026 are weighted equally, and a La Liste rating moves the total slightly. Nothing a hotel supplies about itself enters the score, and the full formula is published on the methodology page so any figure in the table can be reproduced from the awards beside it.
September to early December is the strongest and tightest stretch, covering the autumn cultural season and the weeks between Thanksgiving and New Year; late January and February are the softest, and humid July and August bring shorter business stays and more availability.
Midtown between Fifth and Park Avenues holds the historic grand hotels and the shortest walks to the theatre district; the southwest corner of Central Park at Columbus Circle trades street life for elevation and park views; and downtown around Tribeca and Battery Park is quieter after dark with better restaurant density.