finehotels.world Search all hotels   Destinations   Methodology   About
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, New York City, United States

finehotels.world › Destinations › New York City

The best hotels in New York City

Twenty-nine keyed addresses across Manhattan's most guarded blocks

United States · 29 ranked hotels · Updated November 2026

New York City has 29 hotels ranked in the finehotels.world index. Aman New York leads on prestige score at 8.09 out of 10, followed by The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel and Casa Cipriani New York. Of those, 29 hold MICHELIN Keys, 2 hold a Forbes Five Star rating, 5 have placed in The World's 50 Best Hotels, 2 are rated by La Liste.

Ranked hotels29
MICHELIN Keys48
Forbes Five Star2
50 Best listed5
La Liste rated2

Reserve a ranked house

The highest ranked houses in New York City. Each opens a live rate screen for that exact property through our booking partner.

Photographs: The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, supplied by the property (pixcdn.co).

Rates open at our booking partner Stay22 and are live at the moment you look. We store no rates. Bookings may earn us a commission at no cost to you.

No American city on this index carries more MICHELIN Key recognition than New York. All 29 ranked hotels here hold Keys, four of them at the three Key level, and the spread of buildings is as telling as the count: Aman New York inside the 1921 Crown Building, The Carlyle keeping uptown formality on East 76th Street, Casa Cipriani occupying the old Battery Maritime Building at the harbour's edge.

Firmdale brought its patterned English maximalism to SoHo with the Crosby Street Hotel and to midtown with The Whitby, while The Mark, The Fifth Avenue Hotel and Fouquet's New York each stage a louder kind of theatre.

Every ranked hotel in New York City

HotelPrestigeDistinctions
1Aman New York3 Keys · 50 Best · La Liste · 83 rooms8.093 MICHELIN Keys; World's 50 Best No. 25 in 2023, No. 37 in 2024, No. 61 in 2025, No. 87 in 2026; La Liste 98.5
2The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel2 Keys · 50 Best · La Liste · 190 rooms7.042 MICHELIN Keys; World's 50 Best No. 30 in 2024, No. 64 in 2025; La Liste 98.0
3Casa Cipriani New York3 Keys · 47 rooms6.643 MICHELIN Keys
4Crosby Street Hotel, Firmdale Hotels3 Keys · 86 rooms6.643 MICHELIN Keys
5The Fifth Avenue Hotel2 Keys · 50 Best · 149 rooms6.642 MICHELIN Keys; World's 50 Best No. 75 in 2025, No. 78 in 2026
6The Whitby Hotel, Firmdale Hotels3 Keys · 86 rooms6.643 MICHELIN Keys
7The Mark Hotel2 Keys · 50 Best · 152 rooms6.582 MICHELIN Keys; World's 50 Best No. 43 in 2025
8Fouquet’s New York2 Keys · 97 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
9Nine Orchard2 Keys · 113 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
10Pendry Manhattan West2 Keys · 164 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
11The Lowell2 Keys · 74 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
12The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad2 Keys · 250 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
13The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel2 Keys · 100 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
14Waldorf Astoria New York2 Keys · 375 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
15Warren Street Hotel, Firmdale Hotels2 Keys · 69 rooms5.992 MICHELIN Keys
16The Greenwich Hotel1 Key · 50 Best · 88 rooms5.861 MICHELIN Key; World's 50 Best No. 77 in 2025, No. 92 in 2026
17The Peninsula New York1 Key · Forbes · 239 rooms5.591 MICHELIN Key; Forbes Five Star
18The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park1 Key · Forbes · 259 rooms5.591 MICHELIN Key; Forbes Five Star
191 Hotel Central Park1 Key · 234 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
20Baccarat Hotel & Residences1 Key · 114 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
21Faena New York1 Key · 120 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
22The Beekman - A Thompson Hotel1 Key · 287 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
23The Bowery Hotel1 Key · 135 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
24The Hotel Chelsea1 Key · 155 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
25The Ludlow Hotel1 Key · 175 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
26The Mercer1 Key · 73 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
27The Twenty Two New York1 Key · 76 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
28The Wall Street Hotel1 Key · 180 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key
29W New York - Union Square1 Key · 256 rooms5.201 MICHELIN Key

Prestige score is shown out of 10. Sources: MICHELIN Guide 2026 Key selection, Forbes Travel Guide 2026 Star Awards, The World’s 50 Best Hotels 2024 to 2026, La Liste 2026 Top 1000 Hotels.

Where to stay in New York City

The keyed properties fall into three bands: the Upper East Side around Madison and Park, where pre-war residential manners still govern; midtown between Fifth and Sixth avenues, close to the parks and galleries; and downtown in SoHo, NoMad, Tribeca and the Financial District, where converted lofts, ferry terminals and early skyscrapers house most of the recent arrivals.

When to go

The city fills twice a year, through late spring and again from October into the Thanksgiving and Christmas weeks; January, February and the humid stretch of late July and August are the quietest.

Common questions

What are the best hotels in New York City?

By prestige score, the three highest ranked hotels in New York City are Aman New York, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, Casa Cipriani New York. The score is a composite of MICHELIN Keys, Forbes Travel Guide Five Star ratings, placements in The World's 50 Best Hotels for 2024, 2025 and 2026, and La Liste's hotel ratings. finehotels.world tracks 29 award holding hotels in New York City in total.

How many MICHELIN Key hotels are there in New York City?

New York City has 29 hotels holding MICHELIN Keys in this index, of which 4 hold the top rating of three Keys and 11 hold two Keys.

How are the hotels in New York City ranked on this page?

Each hotel is scored on a fixed formula built only from award facts, then shown on a scale of 5.00 to 10.00. MICHELIN Keys carry the most weight, a Forbes Travel Guide Five Star rating adds a flat six points, placements in The World's 50 Best Hotels for 2024, 2025 and 2026 are weighted equally, and a La Liste rating moves the total slightly. Nothing a hotel supplies about itself enters the score, and the full formula is published on the methodology page so any figure in the table can be reproduced from the awards beside it.

When is the best time to visit New York City?

The city fills twice a year, through late spring and again from October into the Thanksgiving and Christmas weeks; January, February and the humid stretch of late July and August are the quietest.

Which area of New York City should you stay in?

The keyed properties fall into three bands: the Upper East Side around Madison and Park, where pre-war residential manners still govern; midtown between Fifth and Sixth avenues, close to the parks and galleries; and downtown in SoHo, NoMad, Tribeca and the Financial District, where converted lofts, ferry terminals and early skyscrapers house most of the recent arrivals.

More in United States