Colombia
4 ranked
hotels in Cartagena
5 MICHELIN Keys · 0 Forbes Five Star · 0 World's 50 Best placings
finehotels.world › Destinations › Cartagena
Walled-city convents, Caribbean light and balconies of bougainvillea
Cartagena has 4 hotels ranked in the finehotels.world index. Casa Pestagua leads on prestige score at 5.99 out of 10, followed by Hotel Casa San Agustin and Hotel Quadrifolio. Of those, 4 hold MICHELIN Keys.
Cartagena's four ranked hotels all hold MICHELIN Keys and all draw on colonial buildings within the walls raised against English and French raiders. Sofitel Legend Santa Clara occupies a seventeenth-century convent in the San Diego quarter, its cloister now an open courtyard, and Casa Pestagua is a restored marquis's mansion with a coral-stone facade and high timber ceilings.
Hotel Casa San Agustin joins three whitewashed houses around a pool built beside a preserved section of aqueduct, while Hotel Quadrifolio keeps to a handful of rooms in a smaller republican-era house. Outside the ramparts the city changes register entirely, from the tower blocks of Bocagrande to the shallow water and mangroves of the Rosario islands, reached by boat in under an hour.
| Hotel | Prestige | Distinctions | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Casa Pestagua2 Keys · 11 rooms | 5.99 | 2 MICHELIN Keys |
| 2 | Hotel Casa San Agustin1 Key · 30 rooms | 5.20 | 1 MICHELIN Key |
| 3 | Hotel Quadrifolio1 Key · 8 rooms | 5.20 | 1 MICHELIN Key |
| 4 | Sofitel Legend Santa Clara Cartagena1 Key · 122 rooms | 5.20 | 1 MICHELIN Key |
Prestige score is shown out of 10. Sources: MICHELIN Guide hotel selection, Forbes Travel Guide 2026 Star Awards, The World’s 50 Best Hotels 2023 to 2025, La Liste Top 1000 Hotels.
The Centro Historico inside the walls, especially the San Diego and Santo Domingo quarters, holds all the ranked properties, with balconied streets and plazas closed to through traffic; Getsemani just outside is younger and noisier by night, Bocagrande is high-rise beachfront, and Baru and the Rosario islands offer clearer water for day trips.
The dry season from December to April is peak, and the weeks around Christmas, New Year and the January literature festival are the hardest to book; the rainiest months from September to November are the quietest, with humidity high all year and Caribbean heat constant.
By prestige score, the three highest ranked hotels in Cartagena are Casa Pestagua, Hotel Casa San Agustin, Hotel Quadrifolio. The score is a composite of MICHELIN Keys, Forbes Travel Guide Five Star ratings, placements in The World's 50 Best Hotels for 2023, 2024 and 2025, and La Liste's hotel ratings. finehotels.world tracks 4 award holding hotels in Cartagena in total.
Cartagena has 4 hotels holding MICHELIN Keys in this index and 1 hold two Keys.
Each hotel is scored on a fixed formula built only from award facts, then shown on a scale of 5.00 to 10.00. MICHELIN Keys carry the most weight, a Forbes Travel Guide Five Star rating adds a flat six points, placements in The World's 50 Best Hotels for 2023, 2024 and 2025 are weighted equally, and a La Liste rating moves the total slightly. Nothing a hotel supplies about itself enters the score, and the full formula is published on the methodology page so any figure in the table can be reproduced from the awards beside it.
The dry season from December to April is peak, and the weeks around Christmas, New Year and the January literature festival are the hardest to book; the rainiest months from September to November are the quietest, with humidity high all year and Caribbean heat constant.
The Centro Historico inside the walls, especially the San Diego and Santo Domingo quarters, holds all the ranked properties, with balconied streets and plazas closed to through traffic; Getsemani just outside is younger and noisier by night, Bocagrande is high-rise beachfront, and Baru and the Rosario islands offer clearer water for day trips.